Custom-designed Cookies

Cookie Flavors

We all have different tastes in cookies. While the much-loved vanilla recipe is usually the go-to cookie flavor, I also offer chocolate sugar cookies, and vanilla-lemon sugar cookies.

Icing Flavors

Why not bring your cookies up a notch?

• Vanilla (this is the standard) icing: Great on any cookie flavor!
• Vanilla and lemon icing: Perfect for a flavor boost on a vanilla or chocolate cookie
• Strawberry and vanilla icing: So, so, SO yummy on a vanilla cookie
• Vanilla and peppermint icing: Scrumptious on a chocolate cookie

Unless you are a “I GOTTA’ HAVE THAT LEMON” kinda’ person, I recommend adding the flavor to either the cookie or the icing, but probably not both.

Cookie Thickness

Some people like their cookies a bit more crunchy. Some like them softer. I bake my cookies at 5/16″ to provide a softer cookie that stays fresher longer. If you absolutely cannot stand a thicker cookie, you’ll have to let me know at the time of booking so I can accommodate your taste.

Cookie Design

This is where it gets really fun! If you have a design you really like, by all means send it to me. I will, to the best of my abilities, mimic that design unless copyright is involved. Please see My Policies page.

If you’re not sure what design you want on your cookies, think about the event or occasion. Is it:

• Formal (generally fewer and more sedate colors, often involving white)
• Informal
• Silly
• Younger attendees
• More mature attendees
• Immature mature attendees (wink, wink)
• Cutesy
• Romantic
• Congratulatory
• Religious
• Patriotic
• Celebratory
• Sporty
• Somber
• Girlie
• Bro (or is it “bruh” now?)

The more information you can give me about an event or gathering, the happier we will both be with the result. Think about what you want people to think when they see and bite into the cookies. If the cookies are to showcase one person, tell me about that person. If they are for a group, let me know about the group. If they are for a child, let me know what he or she is really into at the moment. (Hopefully it won’t change before the event!)

Pricing and Minimum Order

For full-size (3-4 1/2″) cookies, the minimum to order is 1 dozen. I can do 3 designs within the dozen but they must all have the same (no more than) 4-color palette. Pricing begins at $36/dozen. Larger cookies, the intricacy of the design, and additional colors of the design will affect the price.

You will see cookies priced much higher than mine around the US (and even in Wyoming), and you will definitely see cookies priced lower than mine in grocery stores. My advice is to please purchase only what you can afford. I price my items well below the national average of custom cookie creators and still allow myself some profit. I don’t overprice because I really want others to enjoy what I do, and I respect how hard the people in Wyoming work for their money. Obviously material costs are continually on the rise, but I will keep an eye on my costs and my pricing to make sure I’m offering you the best price I can.

Please head on over to My Polices page, where many questions will likely be answered. If you don’t find the answer you’re looking for, please feel free to reach out on my Contact page.